Source: Bruce Perkins

England v France Exeter 16 November 2019 – Return Duel

  • +1

France have lost to England three times this year; no wonder they are taking things so seriously.

They were badly outplayed only in the Six Nations game at Doncaster last season, and even there they won the second half 26-17. But they are finding it difficult at present to get on top and stay there.

Their squad:
15 Trémoulière
14 Boujard
13 Boudaud
12 Vernier
11 Jason
10 Peyronnet
9 Sansus
1 Deshayes
2 Sochat
3 Joyeux
4 Corson
5 N’Diaye
6 Ferer
7 Hermet (captain)
8 Ménager R

16 Thomas
17 Domain
18 Traoré
19 Roux
20 Annery
21 Bourdon
22 Castel
23 Ménager M

We really shouldn’t be surprised any more by French selections, but there it is: a nominee for World Player of the Year reduced to the bench – Pauline Bourdon. Her replacement Laure Sansus has to be watched carefully. The two tries she scored direct from set scrums in the Super Series were remarkable. Ian Jason who replaces Marine Ménager on the left wing was rather shown up by her opposite number at Doncaster. Caroline Drouin disappears from No 10, presumably injured.

This year’s autumn programme is the first time the Red Roses have played back-to-back games against major opponents. It’s another sign of how women’s rugby is being notched up.

The England squad:
15 McKenna
14 Thompson
13 Scarratt
12 Harrison
11 Dow
10 Daley-Mclean
9 Riley
1 Botterman
2 Davies
3 Bern
4 Aldcroft
5 Scott A
6 Beckett
7 Packer
8 Hunter (captain)

16 Kerr
17 Perry
18 Brown
19 Cleall P
20 Fleetwood
21 Hunt
22 Scott E
23 Breach

Simon Middleton is obviously very impressed with Abby Dow’s form. Despite the expected return of Lydia Thompson to the right wing – she was the only player unemployed last week – Dow is retained on the other wing where she has not yet represented her country. Indeed it’s hard to remember when she last played there at all.

No surprise that the same pack starts, but it’s a feather in Sarah Beckett’s cap that she gets the nod again over the redoubtable Poppy Cleall.

It’s a daunting thought that over a quarter of the 28 contracted players are unavailable: Amber Reed, Amy Cokayne, Cath O’Donnell, Vickii Cornborough, Lagi Tuima, Claudia Macdonald, Bryony Cleall and Kelly Smith.

Elsewhere
In a very real sense the Scotland-Wales clash at Scotstoun this weekend is far more important than the Exeter game. The qualification matches for the one World Cup place available will be decided next autumn. The contestants are Ireland, Italy, Scotland and Spain.

Philip Doyle, Scotland’s head coach, has made no secret of the fact that that qualification is the top priority for him and his squad. He was delighted with the two wins in South Africa but bigger challenges lie ahead. He has appointed Rachel Malcolm of Loughborough Lightning his new captain for the autumn series

Matches being played this autumn:
Spain v Wales 29-5
Ireland v Wales 13-15
Scotland v Wales 17 November

Current rankings: Spain 8th, Wales 9th, Ireland 10th, Scotland 11th

Leave a Reply

Your e-mail address will not be published. Required fields are marked *